Monday, March 10, 2014

Form and Void - True Detective - Part 1....

2012
"Form and Void" takes place entirely in 2012, as we've caught up with all the other timelines.  All that is left is for Rust and Cohle to connect what they have to Lawnmower Man, finding out exactly who he is.

What we know
The killer is most likely and illegitimate child from one of the Tuttles, possibly a Childress based on a common name between their interview with the domestic and tampered police records.  It's apparent the Childress family has connections in law enforcement as well, just as the Tuttles have connections throughout the state, with resources to hide this practice that has gone on for, apparently, generations, by, ostensibly, many men in the Tuttle family and extended family.  The killer likely collected the victims for the child sacrifices and whatever other unspeakable acts the Tuttles did to them, and may or may not have participated in the rituals himself. 

For the first time in the series, we know more than Rust and Marty.  Until this point, they've been doling out zero new information to Suck and Fuck, holding back things like the Ledoux murder and the reason for their split.  Now, we know exactly who the killer is and what he looks like.  We know he does landscape type work by contract for public entities and schools.  It's time for Rust and Marty to catch the viewers, the Tralfamadorians.

Solving for Childress
The sheriff turns out to be a giant asshole but not more complicit in the YK killings than anyone else.  He admits his reports were altered by Sheriff Childress, but Childress' death makes it a dead end for Rust and Marty.

Back to square one, Marty focuses on the green ears and notices the freshly painted house from their old casefiles.  Going to the house, then to the grandmother who lived there, they get enough information to run down the lead.  Using tax records again, they look up the woman's husband's records using his employer, finding the painters that did the house via the write off, then running down the painters via business license.

Lo and behold, it's Childress again.

I assume they get the address from the expired business license.  Marty and Rust go there to apprehend him for the gruesome crime of operating without a license.

Rust's insurance policy is to mail his evidence, including copies of the tape, to local and national news outlets, as well as law enforcement agencies, should anything happen to him. If you're looking into police corruption, it never hurts to have a cop hating ex sniper on your side.

The Never Ending Loop
The raid on the Childress place brings to mind the raid on the Ledoux place.  Again, Marty goes off on his own throughout the house and makes some gruesome discoveries.  Only this time, the suspect makes off, leading him on a chase into Carcosa, which appears to be their home field for all the sacrifice.  Again, the suspects gets his head blowed off.  Again, they can't find all the answers they need.  Again, they recover prisoners from the compound.

The End
Before the hand to hand combat in the arena, Childress confirms he was the ringleader back in 1995 as well with Ledoux and friend learning from him*.  Amazingly, Marty and Rust survive, despite Childress plunging a knife into Rust and wailing a hatchet into Marty.  Marty is even happy for the first time in the series when he sees his ex wife and daughters visit him in the hospital.

* I get the sense more and more that Ledoux was a 'wannabe' or 'poseur' in terms of the Yellow King worship.  He was a meth cook who through his twisted family connection was brought into the circle as a pawn and bought into it hard.  When he was kneeling on the ground, he spouted the Yellow King fact sheet and sounded more like a follower than a leader.  

Regardless of how Rust obtained the rest of the evidence, the remains found on Childress' land, along with his imprisoned and stitched closed father are enough for the law and the media to close the case on a lot of these crimes.  Unfortunately, the case still is not built out enough to solidly connect the Tuttles and extended family to these rituals, despite rumor and circumstantial evidence.  Some of the evidence, obtained illegally and belonging to a dead man, is not enough to condemn them, and the remaining Tuttles, one as the attorney general, are able to quash it from at minimum a legal perspective.  The birth records are no help either and were likely altered or destroyed by the Tuttles and blamed on a hurricane or two.

The Yellow King
It appears to be part of the ritual these Tuttles participated in, however, will go unexplained with the participants being dead or unknown.  It's also entirely possible that the remaining Tuttles are far enough removed from this nonsense that they are not quashing it to save their hides, but to save the family name, sincerely believing this is the act of a few mad men tangentially connected to the family.

What I took it to be is that these guys practice devil worship, only instead of the devil they direct their worship to the Yellow King, whatever it is.  It's less important to know the details of the ritual or of their beliefs than to know that they existed and were the impetus for the acts they committed.

The guy they ultimately get had to be incredibly creepy, and Childress was no disaapointment in that respect.  With sister-wife living in filth, his father tied to a bed with his mouth stiched closed, and Chilrdess himself moving in and out of accents like James Moriarty, I had to brush away the imaginary ants crawling over my skin. 

Reaction
My prediction was that this will be panned as the "worst" episode of True Detective.  This is a prediction I made before watching a second of the episode. 

I don't think there is a worst episode however.  I think the first episode was the first episode and did what the first episode was supposed to do...a format that continued all the way until last night when the eight and final episode did what the eighth and final episode was meant to do.  It is difficult to "grade" any episode against anything but itself, as each episode had its own purpose and goals to accomplish.  So how anyone could rate and episode that aims to accomplish one set of performance metrics against an episode that aims to accomplish a different set of performance metrics seems unfair.  But that is the state of television opinion having.

True Detective, more than any other show, subscribes to the beginning-middle-end format.  Usually with a season finale, there are threads raised for where the characters will go in the coming season.  For example, in the waning minutes of Game of Thrones Season One finale, Tyrion is made (acting) Hand of the King, something that will dominate not only his story, but much of the story in Kings Landing in Season Two.  Here, the story is close-ened.*

* I would not be surprised if there are winks and nods to Season One in subsequent seasons, as a way of acknowledging the stories operate in the same universe.  Stephen King does this throughout his works.  For example, Apt Pupil makes note of an Andy Dufresne.  

Much of the answers about the conspiracy were spelled out in Episode Seven, and for the finale's benefit.  Rather than cram a lot into the final hour, we were treated to an incredibly suspenseful Buffalo Bill gladiatorial combat scene in Carcosa.  The episode felt well paced, not feeling like time was wasted or rushed.  It allowed viewers to take everything in, even if you watched certain sequences through your fingers like I did. 

Anytime a show incorporates a mythology, it leaves itself open to criticism no matter how the series ends.  I think the point of incorporating the Yellow King into True Detective is both functional and mystical.  It is functional from the point of giving a reason for the killer(s) to commit these acts, and does it in the name of something besides "devil" worship.  It is mystical in the sense that we don't completely understand it, without it being a supernatural element. As far as we can tell, the Yellow King worship is an unreal escape from the world, just as how Rust views religion in general.

The Yellow King drives readers insane in Chambers' works. 

The Carcosa mythology extends decades, across multiple authors, and does not exactly connect.  This is an extension of that.

It is going to be a lot of fun to watch these dvd commentaries.



The Internets love True Detective.  (It also hates it, so don't worry, contrarians.)  If you are looking for good sources on the show, read Andrew Romano of The Daily Beast* and Issac Chotiner of the New Republic both do deep analysis.  Molly Lambert of Grantland does a fine job as well.  I found myself referring to Den of Geek a lot for a lot of the straight of research involved with actively viewing the show.  Tangentially, there is a lot of information on the Yellow mythology out there, including a wiki.  You can also download Robert Chambers The King in Yellow for ninety nine cents to your Kindle.

* All of these are great, but Romano's posts are some seriously excellent television writing.  It brings to mind Todd Vanderwerff's Deadwood posts. 


No comments:

Post a Comment